The most “Chaotic evil” way is to kill both chiefs and their men, i.e.
to cause utter chaos at the camp.
Note that, from the player’s point of view, both solutions are equal.
Both of them end the conflict and reward you with lots of experience.
The whole story starts right after you enter the camp, when you are approached by a girl namedJessie.
She asks you to save her friendRalphy.
Use Lock picking, or the shovel on the smaller totem to save him.
She is the daughter ofCasey James- the Atchisonian leader.
After you save Ralphy, you could find Jesse close to the playground.
Go to the Atchisonians’s camp to visit their chief.
talk to him about the bombs and ask if he really wants peace.
Then, mention thatJesse (almost) died in an explosion.
Tell him that he should end the conflict and both tribes can use theGolden Spiketo repair the railway.
Then, he will agree to meetKakkehbah.
Return to the Topekan part.
During the conversation withKakkehbah, he will ask why he should agree to peace.
Tell him what he told you earlier, thateven the strongest man needs two hands to conduct a train.
Kakkehbah agrees to the meeting.
Go to the Atchisonian gate, where you meet James and his men.
Talk to James, then to Kakkehbah and present the conditions of peace.
it’s possible for you to turn off the lights on the generator at the back of the building.
before you get going tampering with it,shut down the alarm.
When you cut off the power, Kekkahbah will send someone to see what happened.
Now, it’s possible for you to enter through themain entranceand sneak up to theSpike.
It is going to be completely dark so, one man will have no problems getting there.
Remember that the Spike ids locked up so, send outsomeone with Lockpicking.
Obtain the brake shoe for Kakkehbah
It is much easier to do that, than to obtain theSpike.
The shoe is hidden in the swing, in front ofJames’shouse.
You only need to destroy it.
Kill either of the chiefs, or both- also the death of the chiefs ends the conflict.

It is much easier to kill James, because you will only fight with him and Chisel.
Kakkehbah is tough, because of the guards.
It is best to sneak in, through the side entrance.
This site is not associated with and/or endorsed by the Deep Silver / Koch Media or inXile Entertainment.
All logos and images are copyrighted by their respective owners.